Ryobi sells two full-size 18V drills that look nearly alike on the shelf. One is the plain brushed ONE+ drill/driver that has lived in my garage for years. The other wears an HP badge, runs a brushless motor, and beats mine in every row of the comparison chart.
I’ve argued before that brushless is worth paying for on some tools and wasted on others, and after an honest look at how I use a drill, mine belongs in the second group. The stronger model would have helped on one job I can remember. Everything else I’ve asked of the cheap one, it has done. If my drill died tomorrow, I’d walk past the HP version and buy the same $59 tool again.
The HP drill wins on paper
More torque, more speed, and a tougher build
My PCL206 Ryobi Drill tops out at 515 in-lbs of torque and 1,750 RPM. Ryobi’s current HP brushless drill/driver reaches 850 in-lbs, which the company pegs at 65% more than my model, and its two-speed gearbox climbs to 2,150 RPM. It also gets a metal ratcheting chuck and a die-cast gear case. A brushless motor turns less of the battery into heat, so each charge stretches further.
None of this is marketing fluff. As a mechanical engineer, I respect every one of those gains. The catch is that a torque rating describes a ceiling. Like most power tool specs, it tells you what the tool can do at its limit and nothing about what your projects ask of it. A homeowner’s drill spends very little of its life anywhere near that limit.
Most of my work never reaches that ceiling
Pilot holes don’t need 850 in-lbs
Count up what a drill does around a house in a year. Mine bores pilot holes, sets hinge and cabinet screws, and occasionally pushes a larger bit through a joist for an Ethernet run. When I mounted a folding squat rack, the drill’s whole job was drilling a handful of clean pilot holes in the studs. The lag bolts went to my impact driver, because they’re built for different work.
That split matters. Heavy fastening is the task most likely to expose a weak drill, and in my garage it never reaches the drill at all. What remains is light work in short bursts. A 3/16-inch bit cutting into pine draws a fraction of what either motor can deliver, so the extra 335 in-lbs would sit unused.
The two times my drill struggled
Low gear fixed one, and torque wouldn’t have fixed the other
Hole saws were the first problem. Cutting grommet holes through a solid wood desktop, and later duct openings in my basement, the drill bogged whenever I left it in high gear. Sliding the switch to gear 1 settled it. The cuts went slower, and every one of them finished.
The second job was worse. At my old house, I built an 8×12 shed and had to drill into its concrete slab for the anchors. The PCL206 crawled. I backed off the trigger, worked in short stretches, and kept setting the drill down so the motor could cool. It was a long afternoon.
A stronger drill/driver wouldn’t have saved me there, though. Neither my drill nor the HP drill/driver has a hammer mode, and concrete wants percussion more than twist. The right tool was Ryobi’s HP brushless hammer drill, which adds up to 34,000 blows per minute. My drill did fall short that day. It fell short at a job I’ve done once.
The price gap buys something I use more
A battery works in every tool I own
Bare (tool only), the PCL206 lists at about $54. The HP drill/driver typically costs close to double, and the hammer version climbs from there. That difference covers most of a new 18V pack.
A battery pack earns its keep in ways a torque number can’t. It clips onto more than 20 ONE+ tools in my garage, from the circular saw to the tire inflator. Extra drill torque helps on a few holes a year. I learned a while ago that the battery is the real investment on this platform, and a spare one has rescued more stalled Saturday projects than a bigger motor ever would.
The right drill depends on how often you push it
The HP drill earns its price for people who lean on a drill hard. If you run hole saws most weekends, bore large holes through framing, or drill masonry more than once a decade, buy it, and get the hammer version. I’m not that buyer.
My drill makes small holes, drives small screws, and hands the hard jobs to the impact driver. Before you pay for the upgrade, think back over your last 10 projects and count the times your drill ran out of muscle. If that number is close to zero, the cheaper drill and a fresh battery will take you further.