18 - Nov - 2026

4 thrillers where you can’t trust the person telling the story

A good thriller keeps you guessing, but some movies take things a step further by making you question the person telling the story. They introduce characters who have twisted reasons for hiding the truth, memories that don’t always match what’s real, and details that seem perfectly reasonable until you look at them differently.

Just when you think you’ve figured out what’s going on, something changes your understanding of the entire plot. Instead of just hiding the answers, these movies give you reasons to believe one version of events before making you doubt everything. If you enjoy thrillers that keep you guessing beyond the obvious questions, these four movies are worth watching.

The Usual Suspects (1995)

A criminal recounts the events behind a deadly incident

The Usual Suspects begins when small-time criminal Roger “Verbal” Kint (Kevin Spacey) survives a deadly incident aboard a ship. During questioning by U.S. Customs agent Dave Kujan (Chazz Palminteri), Verbal agrees to thoroughly recount how he and four other criminals became involved in a series of events connected to the super mysterious Keyser Söze.

As he relays the story, the investigation becomes about conflicting motives and a man whose identity no one knows for sure. The best thing about The Usual Suspects is that the entire story hinges on what Verbal tells the investigator. He connects different characters and explains how they all became involved in the events leading up to the incident on the ship.

It’s easy to follow along because his version of events gives everything a clear direction. But Verbal is also a criminal being questioned by the authorities, which gives him reasons to be selective about what he reveals. The movie uses this to make you question how much of his story you should accept. The ending is surprising, but some viewers just might see it coming.

Memento (2000)

A man with memory loss tries to find his wife’s killer

Memento chronicles the life of former insurance investigator Leonard Shelby (Guy Pearce), who can’t form new memories after suffering a head injury. He’s also searching for the person responsible for his wife’s murder, which means he has to use photographs, handwritten notes, tattoos, and other people to keep track of the information he discovers.

Although a bunch of solid clues might seem like a reliable way to solve the mystery, Leonard’s use of them has a problem. He can’t always remember why he wrote something down or what happened before he took a photograph. The movie also tells its story out of chronological order, which means viewers have to piece together events without always knowing what led to them.

All of this makes Memento different from a standard murder mystery because the question isn’t just whether Leonard will find the killer. It’s also whether he can trust the information he’s using to get there. He also comes across as a sympathetic character who is very easy to root for, which is why the truth about his wife’s murder will break you.

Shutter Island (2010)

A missing patient leads a detective into a strange mystery

Shutter Island follows U.S. Marshal Teddy Daniels (Leonardo DiCaprio), who travels to a psychiatric hospital on a remote island with his partner, Chuck Aule (Mark Ruffalo). They’re investigating the disappearance of a patient. But the staff is reluctant to provide straightforward answers, and Teddy begins to suspect that the hospital is hiding something.

His own history also becomes important as the investigation takes increasingly strange turns. The movie makes it easy to understand why Teddy becomes suspicious. Especially since some of the clues he discovers seem to support his belief that something is wrong. But his flashbacks and personal experiences make it harder to separate what he’s investigating from what he believes.

That’s the part that keeps Shutter Island interesting. You’re trying to work out what’s going on at the hospital while also questioning whether Teddy’s interpretation of the evidence is correct. The movie gives you lots of reasons to share his suspicions without making it easy to know where they will lead. And the final reveal is completely unexpected.

The Woman in the Window (2021)

A woman witnessed a crime, but can she trust what she saw?

Anna with wet hair Credit: Netflix

The Woman in the Window tells the story of agoraphobic psychologist Anna Fox (Amy Adams), who spends her days inside her home. She passes the time watching her neighbors through the windows of her apartment, including the Russell family, who recently moved in across the street. But Anna’s quiet life is turned upside down when she witnesses a stabbing in their home.

As Anna desperately tries to figure out what happened, she realizes that convincing others of what she saw isn’t as easy as she expected. What makes the story interesting is that Anna isn’t the most reliable person. Her anxiety, isolation, medication, and alcohol addiction give others reasons to doubt her, even when she says she knows what she saw.

That leaves you trying to work out whether the people around Anna are hiding something or whether she’s misunderstood what’s actually happening. Unlike a thriller where the main character can follow the evidence wherever it leads, Anna has to deal with the possibility that her own perspective is part of the problem. And her own tragic backstory doesn’t help.

The power of an unreliable narrator

When the truth changes everything

Watching a thriller through the eyes of an unreliable narrator changes the way you experience the entire story. In a typical mystery, the clues you’re given lead to a conclusion that makes perfect sense. But when the end of the movie turns everything upside down, you start to wonder how you could have trusted the wrong person.

It also puts you in the shoes of the characters who may have just as much trouble figuring out what’s true. So instead of simply waiting for a big reveal, you’re constantly weighing up what you know, what you suspect, and what might not add up. When a thriller pulls this off, the twist does more than surprise you. It changes how you understand the story that came before it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *