17 - Nov - 2026

This is why I won’t ever buy a Pixel Watch

I wear a smartwatch for one main reason: keeping track of my health and fitness. When I was using an iPhone every day, my Apple Watch was pretty much glued to my wrist. It tracked my workouts, monitored my sleep, and, as silly as those little rings might seem, constantly gave me that extra push to get up and move.

So, when I eventually switched to a Pixel, getting a Pixel Watch felt like the obvious next step. But while looking into the Pixel Watch and everything it could do, I came across one thing that completely changed my mind. In fact, it’s probably the biggest reason I wouldn’t buy one.

Google put my gains behind a paywall

The watch knows more, but it won’t tell me

By now, you probably get just how important health and fitness insights are to me when I’m choosing a smartwatch. I don’t wear one just to glance at my step count at the end of the day. I want it to tell me more about what’s happening with my body, whether I slept well, how hard I’ve been training, if I should take things a little easier today, or whether all those morning walks and workouts are paying off over time.

And to be clear, my problem isn’t that Google is bad at any of this. Quite the opposite, actually. From what I’ve tried, the Pixel Watch offers some of the best health tracking on a smartwatch. You’re getting heart rate and HRV tracking, SpO2, sleep scores, cardio load, health trends, and all the everyday numbers I regularly check, like steps, calories burned, and distance. There’s already a pretty comprehensive picture of your health sitting on your wrist.

The problem starts when I want the watch to make more sense of all that data. Personalized workout recommendations, detailed sleep coaching, and guided mindfulness are exactly the kind of things I’d turn to regularly. I don’t necessarily need another screen throwing numbers at me.

Google Pixel Watch 3 worn on hand Credit: Zarif Ali / MakeUseOf

I want my smartwatch to connect the dots and tell me what those numbers mean for my day. If I’ve slept terribly for a couple of nights, should I take it easier at the gym? Has my resting heart rate been trending downward over the past month? Am I getting fitter, or does it just feel like I am?

I’d also love being able to ask Gemini questions about my own data. Instead of jumping between graphs and trying to spot patterns myself, I could ask how my resting heart rate has changed recently or whether my fitness has improved over the past few months. That’s where all the information the watch has been collecting becomes much more meaningful. Except, once again, some of these deeper insights and tools require a subscription.

This is more my kind of healthy relationship

A workout with recurring charges

That’s where the Pixel Watch becomes a much harder sell for me. It’s not that I’m completely against paying for subscriptions. If I owned the watch, I could easily see myself eventually giving in because I’d want the complete experience. But that brings me straight back to the question bothering me in the first place: why should I have to?

If I’m already spending close to $400 on a smartwatch largely because I care about its health and fitness capabilities, being asked to pay every month to get more out of the data it’s already collecting just doesn’t sit right with me. At that price, I don’t want to feel like I’ve bought the watch but still need another recurring payment to experience everything that made me interested in it in the first place.

That becomes even harder for me to justify when I look at what Samsung offers on a Galaxy Watch. Most of the health and fitness experience I care about is available without asking me to pay anything extra every month. Galaxy AI can use my Energy Score to give me personalized insights, while overnight temperature tracking, heart health features, daily cardio load, Running Coach, and Samsung Health wellness insights are all part of the experience.

Samsung Galaxy Watch 9 on a person's wrist Credit: Shimul Sood / MakeUseOf

And that’s much closer to how I want a smartwatch to work. I buy the watch, wear it every day, let it learn from my sleep, workouts, and general activity, and then use those insights to make better decisions about my routine. I don’t want to constantly wonder whether the next layer of information will ask me to pull out my credit card.

Sure, you can use subscriptions alongside a Galaxy Watch. The iFIT workout library costs extra, and Strava has its own paid tier, but I see those differently. They’re separate services that I can choose to use if I want them, rather than core Samsung Health features I need to pay extra to unlock.

That difference matters to me. If Samsung can give me this much from the moment I buy the watch, without adding another monthly payment to the pile, it’s hard for me to accept Google taking a different approach. With a Galaxy Watch, it feels much closer to a one-time investment: buy the hardware and get the health experience that convinced me to buy it in the first place.

Pixel perfect, until the bill arrives

I really wanted the Pixel Watch to be the obvious companion to my Pixel. I like the design, I already enjoy Google’s ecosystem, and having everything work together would make my life a little easier. But a smartwatch is also one of the most personal gadgets I own. It sits on my wrist all day, follows me to the gym, and even goes to bed with me.

If I’m trusting it with that much of my routine, I want to get as much as possible from it without wondering what another monthly payment might unlock. Maybe that won’t bother everyone, but it matters enough to me that I’d happily give up the tighter Pixel integration and wear something else instead. Until that changes, the Pixel Watch isn’t going on my wrist.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *